On 2 April 2026, the Trade Competition Commission of Thailand (TCCT) decided that the refusal to renew Villa Market's supermarket lease at The Shoppes Grand Rama 9 At Bell, Bangkok, was an unfair trade practice under section 57 of the Trade Competition Act B.E. 2560 (2017). The TCCT published the decision on 16 November 2026. VA Partners advised the complainant, Villa Market JP Co., Ltd., on the economics of the case, working alongside the law firm WCP, which advised on the legal side.
Villa Market's lease allowed up to four further three-year terms, with a limit on rent increases at each renewal. In 2020 the landlord, Bell Development Co., Ltd., part of the Central Pattana group, declined to renew, saying it planned to improve the space, and later offered a total rent of THB 1,000 per square metre, 148.44 per cent above the THB 402.50 Villa Market had been paying. Villa Market left in September 2020. In December 2020 a Tops supermarket run by Central Food Retail Co., Ltd., part of the same wider group, opened in the same unit at a flat total rent of THB 530.46 per square metre.
The TCCT found unanimously that Bell Development, acting through the person who signed its notices, used superior bargaining power to impose terms that limited Villa Market's business choices and refused to deal with it without good reason, contrary to section 57(2) and (3). By four votes to two, it also found that Central Food Retail, with an individual acting for it, unfairly interfered in the renewal, contrary to section 57(3), having prepared a store layout for the same unit while Villa Market was still the tenant and talks were still open. The two dissenting members saw this as ordinary competition for the space. The TCCT fined Bell Development THB 6,629,946.50 and Central Food Retail THB 11,592,000, each 10 per cent of the relevant 2020 revenue, and the two individuals 10 per cent of those amounts.
The TCCT looked at two linked markets, renting retail space suited to supermarkets and supermarket retailing, across Bangkok and its vicinity. It also looked at the rental market within 3 kilometres of the centre, since shoppers mostly choose a supermarket near home or work. It found neither company dominant under section 50, and based the section 57 findings on bargaining power. A market share above 10 per cent may indicate market power, and superior bargaining power can come from the cost of switching: leaving meant losing the fit-out investment and the years spent building a customer base, even though its dealings with the landlord were under 30 per cent of its revenue. The rent offered to Villa Market was higher than that of other supermarkets within 3 and 5 kilometres, and well above what the replacement tenant paid. The TCCT treated this as raising a rival's costs and shutting it out of a scarce location, and considered that the common group link gave the landlord's side a way to use its bargaining power, and information about a rival, in favour of its own supermarket.
The decision is relevant to landlords that also run retail businesses and to tenants renewing leases with them. The full decision, in Thai, is on the TCCT website. More on VA Partners' competition work: Antitrust & Competition.